Our Bakery Menu

Each pie crust is handmade and baked fresh to order. We use the highest quality ingredients - like King Arthur flour, Bob’s Red Mill, locally farmed eggs and dairy.

Please allow a minimum of 48 hours for pickup once your order is placed. Available for pick-up at any Sunnyside Diner or Classen Grill!

  • Apple Pie

    A timeless American classic, this pie features tender, cinnamon-kissed, tart apples.

  • Blueberry

    Juicy blueberries bursting with flavor, -a taste of summer in every bite. Available and appropriate for any time of year. Available with a crumble topping.

  • Cherry

    A combination of sweet and tart cherries, accented with vanilla and almond. A classic that’s always in season. Available with a crumble topping.

  • Chocolate Mocha

    Rich chocolate meets velvety mocha in a heavenly pairing, topped with fresh whipped cream

  • Coconut Cream

    Escape to the tropics with our luscious coconut custard pie, topped with fresh whipped cream.

  • Key Lime

    Tangy key lime filling in a hand-shaped graham cracker crust, topped with fresh whipped cream.

  • Lemon Buttermilk

    Luscious lemon and creamy buttermilk in a harmonious blend, topped with fresh whipped cream.

  • Mixed Berry

    A vibrant medley of flavorful summer berries. Available with a crumble topping.

  • Peach

    Peaches with a hint of ginger- a taste of summer in every bite. Available with a crumble topping.

  • Peanut Butter

    Rich peanut butter baked into a chocolate cookie crumble with fresh whipped cream. Allergy alert - Peanuts

  • Banana Walnut

    Gluten free, plant based.

  • Brioche Buns

    Golden brown with a buttery top. Order by the ½ dozen.

  • Brioche Loaf

    Available pre-sliced or whole. Order as a full or ½ loaf.

  • Cranberry Pecan

    Sweet & tangy.

  • Green Chile Focaccia

    Savory, crispy and airy Italian bread made with green chiles.

  • Jalapeno Cheddar Biscuits

    Fluffy cheddar jalapeno biscuit with finishing salt sprinkled on top. Order by the ½ dozen.

  • Kaiser Buns

    Soft and fluffy with a crispy top. Order by the ½ dozen.

  • Pumpkin

    Gluten free, topped with toasted pepitas.

  • Sourdough

    Available pre-sliced or whole. Order as a full or ½ loaf.

  • Cookies

    Flavors available: Chocolate Chip, Ginger Molasses, Oatmeal Raisin, Lemon Sugar, Gluten Free Oatmeal Chocolate Chip.
    Order by ½ or full dozen.
    Mix and match also available

  • Take & Bake Cookie Dough

    Pre-portioned, makes about 12 cookies. Choose Ginger Molasses or Chocolate Chip.

  • Frosted Cookies

    Vanilla frosted cookies with sprinkles. Order by the ½ dozen. Available in a variety of shapes & sizes - let us know the occasion!

  • Double Lemon Cake

    Gluten free, zesty cake made with real lemons.

  • Orange Marmalade Cake

    Zesty cake made with real oranges.

Have a question or special request? Let us know!